5 Stars!!! Friendly staff and the owner was wonderful! Made us feel safe with hand sanitizer at the door and masks required. We chatted for over 15minutes and the pie was AMAZING!

I was overwhelmed with the choices! Everything I bought has been amazing so far & I will definately be going back soon! I am a Central Fl native & love my home grown stuff. The homemade key lime ice cream was to die for. The key lime wine was amazing. The key lime pie was as check puckering, tart as you would expect it to be! Cant wait to go back!!!

I never got the chance to go inside of this store because I was soooooo mesmerized by their amazing rescue alligator, sweetie. I was so enchanted by her perfection that I completely forgot to go in and visit this lovely store. Sweetie was such an amazing creature, she and I cuddled for quite a while. This place is absolutely worth a visit for this experience alone, it’s a chance of a lifetime. I cannot wait to go back and visit this little store as well :)

Love Love LOVE this place. Delicious Key Lime Pie, devilishly good cheesecake and tons of great gift ideas for loved ones. It is a MUST when family is in town or looking for a delectable splurge.

I loved this shop.so many things to choose from. I bought lots of different things to try. Key lime pretzels are amazing. The staff were so friendly and helpful. The ice cream section had so many flavours to choose from and samples provided to help you decide. Its clean and tidy and very well presented. The walls are beautifully decorated and the pavement outside too

Excellent key lime pie! Creamy, and authentic key limes are used! Bought a piece to try and it was so delicious we decided to bring home a whole frozen pie to take home after our vacation. Will definitely return when we are back to the Cape Canaveral area.

Delicious!! We had the key lime pie and vanilla cheesecake. Too bad we went on our last day of vacation. Im sure the ice cream would have been great too!

I went there one day and the lady was amazing and really sweet so much so that I bought more than I normally would able because I wanted to give her more business. I decided to go a few days later and sadly the experience was quite the opposite, an older man was rude and decided that his phone was more important than his customers. I have never seen someone care more about his phone than assisting a customer. Hopefully if you go you get the nice lady and not this older gentleman.

Had the pleasure of visiting Florida Key Lime Pie Company yesterday. Amanda helped my buddy and I out by selling us a frozen key lime pie so that it would keep for our long drive back home. We experienced great customer service and the pie was amazing! I am very thankful.

Great pie. Most people make it too sweet for me but this one was just the right tartness.

Great service and great ice cream. Plum-rum and Key lime pie ice cream the best. Awesome hot sauces. Must see and visit if in the area.

Locally owned shop. Has some ice cream that the kids like, key lime pie that the wife enjoys and a wide variety of hot sauce for me. Throw in a bunch of local/craft beer, soda, wine and a variety of other stuff. Worth popping into if nothing else than just to check it out and support local business

First time visiting Cocoa Beach and I was heartbroken when we arrived 10 minutes after the shop had closed for the night. Still we took selfies and then began a search for “The Second-Best Key Lime Pie” in Cocoa Beach.So excited to report that the shop owner saw us outside and asked if we would like to get some pie.OhMyGosh YES!So grateful for his kindness and pleased to report that this really IS the BEST Key Lime Pie in Florida.

I love this place so much! The best part is seeing Amanda! She is so warm and friendly! She has the best personality and makes you feel welcome! She gave us excellent samples of their delicious wine! Every time i have a visitor in town, I make sure to take them here! Amanda, keep up the great work! You are awesome!

Amanda was super nice and helpful. Loved the shop. The key lime pie was delish and the blackberry wine was amazing. If in this area, a must visit!

Key Lime pie is awesome as always! We always get the key lime pretzels too. Good staff, know their stuff, good selection of unique things to try. I always stop here when in Cocoa Beach.

The pies are excellent. The service is outstanding. I love how safe they are with this virus going around. Ive been there twice, and both times Ive felt safe buying edible products from them.

The ice cream is delicious! Every time we come to Cocoa, we will be making a visit. Even if we are just passing through. Thanks for the great experience, Amanda! Youre amazing

The Key Lime pie is so good. Im taking one home to Maryland tomorrow. The young lady was so helpful in telling us how to get it there safely. That is if it makes it there.

Takes COVID precautions very seriously. Highly recommend!

Cute little store. We have been in here several times, but yelling across the store when someone enters asking if they have a mask is ridiculous! You could simply walk over to them and ask!! Not embarrass them. I understand the mask, I don’t understand the need to be rude and loud to a customer when they enter. Even with masks on it seemed that having customers was over whelming and bothersome to the staff. Maybe it was because of the holiday weekend but I won’t be back.

You cant enter until you are sprayed with alcohol because you will be touching candy. Huge selection of homemade candy and goods.

The salt water taffy is incredible, but they icecream is only okay.

This store has a big variety of tasty treats, and we decided to buy several different things, all which were good! Casey was really friendly and helpful! This will be a nice place to bring company when they come to visit!

I have lived in Florida my entire life. Best key lime pie I have ever had.

I visited yesterday (June 24th 2020) while in Cocoa Beach for my birthday. This place did not disappoint one bit.After going in and sampling a few of the wines, I decided to try a piece of their Key Lime pie.The pie was amazing with a perfect blend of tart and sweet.The staff there was extremely friendly, the prices are very fair and their signature treat is awesome.

My friends and I happen to walk into this shop and we’re instantly welcomed by Becca. At first we just walked around aimlessly but then she offered to give us a tasting of their jerky. She was so nice and welcoming and complimented us and gave us so many suggestions on places to eat and visit. She was AMAZING! Like I highly recommend coming and seeing her! She was so helpful and amazing. I love her...if I could marry her I would ️

Came in for free sample, nope they dont offer anymore. Not sure if its covid related, but they shouldnt advertise it on the tourist map. Local items for sale, I bought local cookies for $$.

Neat little shop with free samples of great key lime pie. I enjoyed the fish painted on the ground swimming into the store and to the key lime pie fridge. A few unique artsy things to admire and purchase as well. We bought a slice to go. Enjoy!

Tons of hot sauces to choose from . Every salt water taffy u could imagine.I picked up key lime covered pretzelsCant wait to try itThe only down side is that there are no prices and there were no samples

Amanda was the best. Hot sauce tasting was awesome!

Amazing deserts. Best salt water taffy in Florida. Cute little shop right off the beach a must stop for the Cocoa area

Wonderful warm service. The atmosphere was a fun ocean theme and lots great sweet goodies.

The keylime pie was delicious but the key lime flavored pretzels are really what stand out here, they are unexpectedly good.

One of the things you think of when you think of Florida is Key Lime Pie, and I was very excited when I discovered this store.Upon walking in, the saleswoman was very friendly and explained to us how real key lime pies are made and gave us plenty of samples of key lime pie, cookies, and key lime pie flavored pretzels to try.The cookies and the pretzels were very addictive, so we bought a box of cookies. The key lime pie sample in the store tasted good, so we got a whole pie. Later on, once we got home, we ate a slice, and it tasted much sweeter than it did in the store. I found the pie and the crust to be too sweet for my liking.Overall not a bad pie, just too sweet for me, but those cookies were amazing.

Best key lime pie! Amazing homemade ice cream in unique flavors. 4 stars because they did not have napkins.

Had some of the best coconut cream ice cream Ive ever tasted! Everyone working was so sweet and helpful, recommending various flavors and combinations for ice cream. This will definitely be a place I visit everytime Im at the beach!

Pies are great. Lots of florida foods and spices.

Conveniently located across of Ron Jon Surf Shops North Entrance. If you are visiting from out of town definitely a must visit. The pie is excellent, the staff is friendly, and if your lucky you may encounter another local attraction that will surprise you. Aside from pie, they sell local wines, ice cream, python jerky, honey, a wide variety of hot sauces for those brave enough to try them, and salt water taffy. I purchased a bottle of Dragon Fruit Blush wine made by the Murielle Winery, it was REALLY good, I recommend giving it a try.

Overall it was nice, but not what I had expected from what I read prior to getting there. Let down is a good way to put it. But I would go back to it again

Possibly the best ice cream I ever had (Key Lime).

I promised the owner Id try to get his 4.9 to a 5.0 on the google reviews. This place was awesome and the alligator named Sweetie was super adorable and cool. My mom and I took a pic with her! Their ice cream and key lime pie is also extremely well made. Really glad we stumbled upon this place.

This place is amazing! The murals are unreal and absolutely beautiful. The floor is painted like the ocean floor which is so cool! The man that was working was super knowledgeable and helpful and gave samples. The Key Lime Pie is to die for. Seriously this store is amazing!!!!! And they have alligators that you can come take pictures with on the weekend, wild!

We go here every year. They have tons of locally made snacks, drinks and sauces. Their pie is awesome, though it could use some whipped cream. Their new location is really convenient, right next to Ron Jon. Go. Enjoy. Love it.

My husband and I went to this shop today while on vacation with really high hopes after reading many positive reviews. When we arrived to the shop, I mentioned the ads on their website for a free key lime pie sample to a man who was working there. He said they couldnt honor their ad because of coronavirus (even though they had samples of wine out for people to try, which doesnt really make any sense). My husband and I bought two slices of pie on good faith anyways at $4.50 a slice. When we got back to the hotel room, we realized the slices were very acidic and lacked sweetness (I would go as far as to say that even publix brand is better). We are not sure if we just got a bad batch or what but we were very dissapointed with the flavor and very high cost of the pie slices for the quality (I would be willing to pay even double for a good quality pie btw). Needless to say, if we had gotten the sample, we would not have bought the slices.

Omg the best pie must go if yall are ever by there

Very friendly and so much fun to hang out and pet the alligator out front while getting a cold, delicious treat

Excellent key lime pie. Very friendly staff

Not that many flavors to choose from. Not many good flavors. Worker who served us was pretty obnoxious and rude acting. Better places to go.

Staff was super sweet. Was able to sample the pie, and it was amazing! Bought two pies and other gifts. Even went back for another pie 2 weeks ago. Note, Im not local.

Really great business! Lots of cool stuff! Good Quality product 10/10

Best Key Lime pie I have ever had. Its his great grandmas recipe! Highly recommended.

CAUTION, spraying your hand(s) upon entering. Spray caused burning sensation on back of hand.

I saw your alligator on instagram. I hope he is doing fine. 5/5 for this idea

DELICIOUS PIE!!! We stopped here on our last day in town, and we surely wish we would have come earlier. Not knowing, we just thought they had pie and ice cream, but they have so much more! There are hot sauces, jams, wines, etc. The staff was very helpful, and we were able to take our pie to eat right out front! Next time, this will be a stop on our first day in town!

Walked in for just a slice of key lime pie and got a wine tasting, jerky tasting, and INCREDIBLE customer service. Becca is wonderful, and suggested all sorts of snacks for us, gave us all the answers we asked for, and even helped us find somewhere to go for dinner!

The best Key Lime pie I have ever ate and I have eaten alot lol. I was born and raised in Florida so Ive had quite a bit.

Becca did an excellent job at describing the various item which were tasted. Her guidance and patience was great and made it so much easier to decide on what I should buy.

Ice cream was really good

Casey helped me out and showed me some fantastic wine choices

Becca was amazing! I absolutely recommend checking this place out if you’re in town. They have everything from Key Lime Pie to taffy you hot sauce.

Loved my time here! The deserts and ice cream was amazing! The cashier Rebecca was very friendly and helped me decided on what flavor to get. Definitely recommend this place anytime you’re in Cocoa Beach!

This place has a delicious, fantastic key lime pie! You can buy it by the slice or by the pie. You also can get them frozen, which I recommend. Even in our 15 minute trip down the road to our hotel, the pie slices melted a bit in the Florida heat. They also carry lots of local craft beers, wines, sweet treats and gifts. Its a great place to pick up souvenirs. Ive been told the sangria wine pops are excellent, cant wait to try that!

This place had awesome salt hand scrub, you can even try some in the bathroom. Love the environment this place has

This is a MUST VISIT location if you find yourself near Cape Canaveral!! An awesome and friendly staff helping with questions, samples, ice cream, other treats, sauces, seasonings, and of course key lime pie! I dare you to even TRY getting a sample, youll end up leaving with a scoop of ice cream or pie, and it is all awesome!! We WILL be back!!

It is a small store with a large variety of delicious key lime concoctions. We were able to sample numerous wines. Rebecca was friendly, knowledgeable and demonstrated her expertise with a wide array of special wines. The store is uniquely decorated, bright and inviting. They even have live alligators! Wow!The store is located near Ron Jon’s Surf Shop.

Delicious pies along with jerky, ice cream, and a lot more delicious treats. As well as that there is live music outside with an alligator, and you get the chance to hold a baby alligator inside.

This is the place to go for key lime pie. However if you like your got sauce this is also the place to get something unique. They also have some wine selections and ice cream. Check it out !!

The ice cream flavours are so unique and the key lime pie alone is worth the trip from Canada. Extremely friendly and helpful staff. Thanks Rebecca!

The gentleman at the counter couldnt have been nicer. He welcomed us, offered a sample of pie (spectacular!), and answered questions about his products. He even let us try a sample of a few wines we were considering, and helped us pick the right one for us. A very nice experience..highly recommended!!

Nice people, tourist oriented but not the best key lime. Im a third-generation chef, and I still like Sanibel Florida for the best blend. Pie company too sour..

A cute small shop that has amazing refreshing key lime pies and much more after a Long Beach day

Great customer service, products & PIE. Rebecca was the best & even had a little wine tasting for our party! She also shared that the Key Lime Festival was happening this wknd which we were not aware of. Will definitely come back when in Cocoa Beach

Saw the alligator on instagram... hope he’s chillin

Had live alligator at store for kids to see. Unique ice cream flavors.

Fantastic place to visit. Try the key lime pie, key lime pie pretzels “cocoa beach crack” and the homemade farm to table ice cream!

Cant beat the chocolate dipped keylime pie

Oh my gosh!You have to go!!!Rebecca is the sweetest girl serving sweets!!Thanks so much!God Bless You!

Rebecca was great at helping us to find the right wine & desserts to make our trip awesome. I definitely recommend stopping in.

Superb key lime pie. Really friendly folks as well. Im currently on a mission to explore a bunch of key lime pie houses and recipes. Im especially intrigued that some great ones are baked and other great ones are not. Imagine my surprise to learn that they make theirs in both styles!Nice and sharp with plenty of lime kick. Well be back.

Im a Floridian born and raised and this place has the best pie and ice cream Ive ever had. Rebecca (one of their employees) was super helpful, well mannered, and made sure I was satisfied with every aspect of my visit.

Awesome place! Love the pies! The key lime pretzels are amazing too! Sweetie the alligator is a sweetie!

AMAZING Key Lime Pie! Crazy variety of hot sauces, too! Also bought my sons some alligator jerky! Went back 2 days in a row for some pie!

Great service. Amazing banana ice cream. Yummy

The key lime is delectable when you take a bite it explodes with flavor in your mouth. I love that it’s so close to the beach so right after I have a nice suntan i just hop off and get my favorite snack, the Keylime pretzels...so delish!

Wow...really one of the best key lime ever tried!!!

Awesome little spot. Great place for some local treats!

Great samples! Friendly staff

Stopped in on my mini vacation and no regrets. Service was great, ice cream selection is broad, and I adore the farm to table selection. Definitely gonna stop before heading home. If youre in cocoa beach, make this one stop you dont miss!

Excellent service, very helpful and friendly. Great treats other than the pie.

Hands down the most amazing key lime pie I have ever had! It was So light and airy, it was not the typical cheese cake key lime. Seriously the best. Try their ice cream to! Absolutely the best you will ever have! Thank you from utah!! I will be ordering some to be shipped!!

We had an amazing time at this little key lime store that has lots to offer including a lot more than just key lime pie!! The kids got homemade ice cream in a coconut dish and we even experienced Florida’s wine tasting w Rebecca and left w many bottles! A must try place

Great selection of different products - especially loved the hot sauce and wine displays! My husband found his favorite, hard to find sauce and one of the employees pointed us toward a delicious wine. The selection of flavored taffy is great. Didnt love the fact that there was an alligator, dressed up, with its mouth taped shut when we went.

This place is a MUST VISIT if you are looking for a delicious dessert. When they say best key lime pie they mean it. The store is neatly decorated and family friendly. They also offer ice cream and many other items.

Best darn key lime pie in Florida. Excellent treats all over the store. The cashier knew everything about her products and offered expert advice. That kind of help from someone around 25 years old is rare these days.

Yeah, this place is tiktok famous now.

Delicious key lime pie but also has a bunch of other products to check out! Definitely not a lie that they are the best key lime pie in Florida!

Not very friendly when we were there.

Friendly staff, lots of options to chose from. We came specifically to try to key lime pie but were tempted by many items ranging from local craft beer to sugar scrubs to endless variety of taffy.

If you love key lime pie like me then you’ll love this place. A huge variety to choose from. 10/10