The Eugene O’Neill is a beautiful older theater in the Broadway area. Like many of the older theaters there are challenges with the number of bathrooms especially on the mezzanine level and tight seating, which is common. However, it is a great venue to watch a good play.

Visited for the first time to see book of Mormon! I bought the tickets as a gift for my boyfriend and we had a great time seeing it!The theater is small yet holds a large amount of guests! The staff were friendly and approachable. There was drinks and snacks sold before the show and during intermission.The merchandise was cute! My boyfriend brought the frog!Will definitely see another show at this theater!

Visited in May 2019 to watch The Book of Mormon, very cosy and beautiful theatre. I was seated at the far left hand side but still had a great experience, seats were packed together really tight though. Im 54 and I cant imagine what it was like for everyone else sitting there for over 2 hours.

Great intimate theater. Every seat has a great view. Sound was high quality. Stage was well lit. Staff was very friendly and helpful. Couldnt ask for more from a theater venue. Will definitely return if the opportunity arises.

Went to see Book of Mormon here. I’ve never laughed so much. Such a great show. A small theatre but with such beautiful detailing. We were ushered in and out quickly. I’d really recommend seeing Book of Mormon and was worth every penny. My only small criticism is that the sound system was a little poor in the first half but it was still audible and was fixed for the second half. A bar available. The toilet line was very long. Stunning set. I loved every minute.

Fantastic venue and tip top service. The interior of the venue itself was immaculate. Ornate designs and proper lighting to match. The seats were comfortable unlike other shows Ive been to where youre counting down to the intermission to take a load off your bum.Facilities could have been nicer, but no complaints. The ambiance created for the show was fantastic.

Loved it!!! Highly recommend! Was going to see it in Denver but was canceled cause of covid19.

Beautiful theater near Times Square. My wife and I saw The Book of Mormon here. All the seats seemed good but we were in the front few rows of the mezzanine and could see the entire stage well. The men’s room, as I found out is in the basement and there will be a very long line to use it at intermission.

A very quiet and intimate theater, the exact opposite of what I was expecting! For a show look “Book of Mormon” I was expecting a large theater but this a nice and small theater that over pack the the crowds in. I’m sure there’s not a bad seat in sight! Can’t wait to return in the future.

Another beautiful theater in NYC. Book of Mormon was incredible and absolutely hilarious. Very raunchy so be prepared. If you have thin skin you will be shocked. Lol

Beautiful theater. I dont think there is a bad seat in the house. Sat 2nd row center and it was phenomenal.

Maybe my favorite show on Broadway. Saw it a couple of times and I still cant stop laughing. Its just hilarious. One street from the theater is Broadway last minute center, I recommend to see what can they offer you. Several times i am getting cheaper ticket compared with theater prices

Fabulous location for a show, online seating charts can help you find the best places to sit that do not have obstructed views. We were in the second row and loved the connection with the actors

Pros:- its a small theater, and the seating is really close to the stage- tickets to Book of Mormon were reasonably priced- staff are extremely kind and helpfulCons:- seating is quite tight, but not uncomfortably closeWe bought tickets tickets to Book of Mormon (buy them at the door if possible, youll get ripped off buying them online). Our ticket holder was running a little late, and one of the outdoor attendants were super helpful and let us save our spot in line until they arrived. We got in and got seated, and one of our party was in the bathroom until just after the play started, and the usher helped them get seated. After the play we thought we left our phone and someone helped us look for it (it was in our bag lol). Very impressed with the service.The seating is a little tight to get into, but once seated, the cushions are actually comfy.

Theater showing Book of Mormon. It’s small and cozy but the seats are comfortable, and the show is the best on Broadway yet. Candy & wine (served in sippy cups) are expensive, but that’s to be expected. Good acoustics and great place to watch a show overall.

Had a great time here! Saw Book of Mormon and it was hilarious! The theater was much smaller than I was anticipating which made it easy to find seats and get settled. All the staff were friendly and easily able to direct attendees to the restrooms and the bars. Highly recommend!

WOW! What an amazing theater. The interior of the theater is absolutely stunning. The sound system is state of the art. Every seat has a good view if the theater and it is quite intimate setting to see a musical at this fine theater. We really ENJOYED watching a funny musical at this theater. A+

Saw the Book of Mormon with my boyfriend here as part of our trip to NYC-- which was fantastic by the way. This venue was beautiful on the inside. A good size for the show. Sound was great too (we sat on the left of the theater near the front, facing the stage). I found it interesting as well that they had someone directing people in the bathrooms during intermission. Ive never seen that before but hey! It kept things organized. Overall I love it!!

Beautiful theater! We had seats way in the back and could still see the stage perfectly. Drinks were super expensive, but discounted if you keep the cup!

Classic Broadway setting with comfortable seats overall. The pitch is a little tight, but the staff is extremely well trained and helpful to manage the traffic flow for every guest need.

Amazing show. The book of Mormon, one of the best musicals we have seen. Great humor, everyone is so talented, a must see! The theater is also quite nice with good views from most places. Be prepared, there are not enough restrooms and the intermission queues are ridiculous.

Loved, loved it!! Our first broadway play did not disappoint. It was awesome to get tickets so close to the show time and sit so close. Lucky stars, for sure. Thank you to all the actors as it was an experience we will never forget.

Great location, beautiful theatre inside. Just saw Book of Mormons. An amazingly talented cast and a hilarious show.Just FYI- Exuberantly overpriced drinks(paid $30 for a Vodka tonic and a coke).

The theater was pretty, though the show we saw here was not my favorite (Book of Mormon). The drinks were friggin expensive though! Like, whatever I got cost me 30$ for a glass!? I all ready paid for the tickets, at least let me have a decently priced drink. Also, prices of drinks were not posted, which would have been nice.

Came here to watch The Book of Mormon and it was excellent! Theres a lot of history in the building and is beautiful inside! Just know that itll probably take you a while to get out as the exits are narrow and the walkway has a bit of a weird slant

Charming and very pretty historic theater, but on the smaller side. Our seats were not very good, way up. The show, Chicago, was awesome! With Cuba Gooding Junior!

So we finally watched the book of Mormons. I coukd not and would not compete with the thousands of reviews written on this show - all of course praising it.Difficult to describe in words how much we enjoyed it. It was so funny, so exciting, clever and full with references to various themes, films, current and historical events and figures. Each and every one of the actors were very talented, energetic and charming. We could not stop laughing.

Absolutely beautiful theatre with the friendliest and most helpful staff. Not a bad seat in the place but does get crowded. But worth it to see The Book of Mormon. Mom and I Brought our theatre loving son here for his 17th birthday. Just loved it.

Nothing beats a Broadway show. Saw The Book of Mormon there and it was fantastic. The theatre is relatively small, but to notch. The service at the bar was quick and friendly during the break.

The Book of Mormon was simply fantastic and the Ed, althoughit seats close to 2000?!, feels very intimate! Were early 40-somethings so we grew up with the Trey Parker/Matt Stone humor of Southpark so the tongue in cheek humor wasnt a surprise. We went to TKTS booth at Lincoln center.. BIG WIN! Paid full face for the tix but no junk fees and 179/ea for these seats on a Sat night were totally worth it!! Fantastic time with great laughs.. oh, dont buy a drink before the show or during intermission.. 1 Sprite (SODA) and a bottled water (NOT FIJI) were 14 bucks!!! The guy in line in front of me paid 36 bucks for a double pour of bourbon and a glass of wine!! Ouch!!

Nothing short of amazing. I saw the Book of Mormon here a few weeks ago. Ample seating. Bar area. Wonderful acoustics in the room. Nearby is restaurant row for a bite to eat before or after your show!

Great place to see a show. Seats are a bit small.

Great Theater. Fun play Book of MORMON

Came here for Book of Mormon of course! Beautiful theatre, clean bathrooms. The drinks are a bit pricey but hey, it’s broadway. One of the workers helped someone sitting in an accessible row in front of me move because he didn’t have enough room, she should be recognized for accommodating. One warning: the bathrooms are down a flight of steps so i am unsure if any bathrooms are accessible. Regardless, wonderful show and so glad to have visited.

Smaller and much more intimate than the expected. Book of mormon. What a riot! I think most seats would be just fine! Be prepared. Long lineups for a pee pee await!

Went to see the Book of Mormon because of the bad weather. What a great choice. It was superb. Highly recommend. Lovely theatre

Enjoyable experience. Great show. Good theater. Wish the steps were carpeted or something so it wasnt so noisy when people walked down during the show. Still enjoyable

Went to see the book of Morman and it was as described, so please read reviews first so your not “insulted” or “displeased” with the content.The theatre is amazing, seats are a bit tight but doable for the 2.5 hours...

Was awesome. Book of mormon fantastic. Staff friendly.

We saw the Book of Mormon here and had the best night ever, not only was the show incredible and unbelievably funny, but the venue was the perfect fit. It was cost and the staff were fantastic, we sat in the front of the mezzanine and I couldn’t recommend the location enough, perfect view and vocals.

Saw Book of Mormon at this theater! Love the old theaters in New York with their art deco decor. Small for a theater, and there are not a lot of bathrooms. During intermission the line for the womens restroom wrapped around the stairwell going up two floors.

Magical night going to a Broadway musical to see Tony winner The Book of Mormon

Intimate theatre with a classy interior. Great experience watching Book of Mormon here!

A great intimate venue with good sight lines. The sound is a bit pinched and trebly but not enough to sway the enjoyment of the show. I saw Book of Mormon on a Friday night and it was magnificent!

We loved the show and the theater was beautiful but it was not a comfortable experience. Seats are very narrow and close together so if you have broad shoulders or long legs, its not an easy fit. Staff was very friendly though. Overall, we enjoyed our visit very much.

Nice smaller theater. Despite the size they did a good job of ushering people through restroom and bar lines. The staff was exceptionally friendly and helpful. We enjoyed seeing The book of Mormon here. (Which itself was fantastic)

A great venue to see plays up close and personal.

Went to NYC to see Book of Mormon for a little birthday celebration. The play was amazing and went above my expectations! The atmosphere was wonderful and we received great service.

We saw the Book of Mormon here and had a great time. Classic little theater that feels historic but not old. The $10 Bud Lights were a bit out of line though, despite the take home cup. The staff here were all helpful.

Great theater. Doesnt seem like there is a bad seat in the house. Its easy to get to and has plenty to do in the surrounding area either before or after a show. The seats are on the smaller side (as with all the theaters in NYC) but were surprisingly comfortable. I would definitely go to this theater again.

Here for Book of Mormon!! First Broadway show and it was excellent. A very intimate feel with a big show pizzazz!! The bartenders were quick, funny, and friendly. Everyone seemed very excited for the show, and it did not disappoint!!

Theatre is pretty intimate. Seating is close, so not for the claustrophobic. Bathroom situation is odd, downstairs from the theatre. All that being said it housed Book Of Mormon well. Intimacy of the venue adds to the experience.

We saw the Book of Mormon the musical. What a great show!! Funny and entertaining!! Our seats were great although looking around I don’t think there’s a bad seat in the house. The only thing I would say is that just be prepared.... the drinks and snacks are expensive.

Tight tight seating like a cheap airplane (assumed for the era). Great classic ambiance. Enjoyed book of Mormon, staff was decent. The blockhead in front of me didnt help - obstructed view, not the houses fault.

Theatre layout is great. Could only see maybe 4 or 5 seats that may have had a less than ideal view of the stage. Mens bathroom is in the basement. So if youre in the balcony, its 2 floors down to get to the bathroom.Saw the Book of Mormon The show itself was great with a lot of laughs.

Seats in the mezzanine were a bit on the small side for a guy like me. Width was fine but leg room was a problem and I come in at a pretty standard 6”0. Otherwise everything was really nice. Good sound and nice view from F106-108.

Nice venue, but the seats are tight. Elevation could be better in the orchestra section (if youre not tall, the head in front of you will block the view. A coat check would be nice.

Book of Mormon was amazing! Toilets are nice but takes 20 minutes to clear the line. One bar is not enough and prices are extortionate but not overshadowed by the performance... a small venue but would definitely go again!

Very beautiful, very comfortable theater. It was easy to get in, get out and use the restrooms. Staff at the box office were very helpful and friendly, too.

Great performance! Acceptable seat size. Great view of the stage from anywhere in the place, even our cheaper seats in the back! We saw The Book of Mormon Musical and loved it!

Beautiful, intimate theater. Super friendly ushers and bar tenders. Drinks were expensive, but you can take the reusable cup back for a discount on your next drinks.

Watched book of mormon here. Nice intimate venue and great seats, right near the front.

The show was great (Book of Mormon) and the atmosphere was really friendly and positive! It would be 5 stars but for the eyewatering cost of interval drinks...

Watched Book of Mormon here. High quality production - talented and hilarious. Theater was aesthetically pleasing, staff was pleasant.

Beautiful theater, the play. BOOK OF MORMON. Was hysterically funny, great cast fast moving and raunchy. Have fun!!

Nice venue, seats are comfortable - if a little tight. Staff were very friendly and of course, The Book of Mormon is fantastic.

Book of Mormon on Broadway--Fantastic. Prices are high, but worth it. We were in the back row and still had a good view, but probably should have spent the extra $40 and got a bit closer to the front.

Very beautiful theater but small. You walk in the doors and literally sit down. People complained about the seats but I didnt have a issue but I did sit on the end. Didnt try the adult sippy cups. All the employees were very nice and helpful.

Saw the Book of Mormon, it was a great experience. We were lucky enough to get seats, literally in the last row. There are no bad seats, sight lines and sound were perfect. The audience loved it, which made our groups enjoyment all the better. Before the show we chuckled amongst ourselves as we got the last few tickets at least we didnt have to see the Lion King, after the show on the way out, a very grumpy couple muttered we should have went to the Lion King. If you like to laugh, and irreverence is in your blood, youll love this show. PS - the have a nice selection of cocktails. Enjoy.

I watched the The Book of Mormon show and I recommend it! It was absolutely amazing and the theatre itself is beautiful on its own as well

This cast is amazing! And friendly, they signed autographs and did selfies for the fans after the show. Highly recommended

Spectacular! The Book of Mormon, exquisite theater, fabulous performance.

Ive seen the Book Of Mormon. If you have the pleasure to seat in the middle, there is no other way as you will enjoying it. Maybe you have a seat on the obstructed view places, but even there its a pleasure.Its a very compact theatre, mainly to see the musical, so you have short ways from the main room to the toilet or the bar or the snack stand. So its all very convenient for you.The seats are pleasant and you have a lot of place for your legs. You can snack and drink while seeing the musical, what is not common.

Charming theater that gets absolutely packed!

Charming old theatre, but really has limited space , especially your will feel this during the intermission) .The musical was great! Recommend it !

The Book of Mormon is the best play Ive seen in a long time! The talented cast sang and danced with enthusiasm. Kudos to the production team for putting together a book and music that move along rapidly and hold the audiences full attention. Several songs are still dancing in my head.

I saw Book of Mormon here. The musical was absolutely hilarious! I wouldnt recommend it for young children, as it has some mature themes, but great for older teens and up. The theater itself is relatively small, but a cozy small. When it came time for intermission, the bathroom operation itself was a production. There were people in there instructing what stall to go in, and it moved through quickly. My father, who at the time was injured and using a cane, was directed to a special bathroom and had no wait. This was a great show to see and a very pleasant theater experience!

Lovely old theatre. Went to see Book of Mormon. Fun show, outrageous in a good way! Theatre was cold though with a heavy draft, we were sat near the doors but some method of preventing draft would be good!

Great show but not so comfortable theatre. Its time to change the seating to be better chairs that are comfortable and more leg room. After all the 150 dollars seating should offer that convenience

Beautiful inside & smooth ticket operation! Comfortable & great seating (no bad seats). Only issue...bathroom are downstairs. During intermission, you better hurry because the line will wind upstairs. If you have knee, mobility issues, or a little slower, you need to be aware. The attendant was very snarky! Sometimes mobility issues are not visible!

The stage is well done for the production but the seats may make you feel like a sardine even though you are not large. Still go and enjoy the show.

Great theatre show was amazing THE BOOK OF MORMON good view even from the less expensive seats

The Book of Mormon... I couldnt stop laughing, awesome play!!

The theater itself is well maintained and comfortable. Id have sat on an orange crate, though, if I had to to see Book of Mormon... uproariously funny and completely irreverent.

My husband and I bought tickets to The Book Of Mormon at the box office yesterday for this evenings show. We would give the show 5 stars. However we are very disappointed with the gentleman at the box office. Not only did we find him very unfriendly he was very dishonest with us about the seats. We were very specific with him that we were not interested in sitting separately. He sold us two seats in a box that were not together. My husband had to sit behind me. This man should of been upfront with us and told us the seats were not side by side.

The upside of extra tiny seats and overpriced sippy cups for wine and beer is that you get to pretend you are a five-year-old. Clean and well-designed theatre. Excellent acoustics make the narrations and music vibrant and the tiered and angled seating means every seat is a good seat.

Beautiful old theater with a classic charm. Great professional staff in the house and on the street. They organize the crowds well despite some tight walkways in the theater. Drinks at the bar were well made in souvenir adult sippy cups which enables customers to enjoy their beverages during the show. We had two Gin and Tonics a bag of pretzels and a bag of peanuts and with a $4 tip, it came to $51. The drinks and concessions are a bit pricey, but hey it is a New York theatre. The production of Book of Mormon was incredible, every song was as funny or funnier than the previous. Set and costume changes were seamless and impressive. This is a fun, irreverent evening of theater, although perhaps not for the easily offended or very young audience.

I saw The Book of Mormon here- a brilliant musical. The theater was beautiful and had great accoustics.

Book of Mormon was genuinely one of the funniest productions Ive ever seen

We saw Book of Mormon and it was an incredible experience. The cast was amazing and the sound quality was great. We got lottery tickets so the seats at the very edge and we still got to see everything.

Seats in the lower mezzanine enabled you to see everything, but they are tight! At 5 2, Ive never had my knees rammed into the seat in front of me! Feel badly for taller folks!

Great theater experience and seats were pretty comfy for Broadway. Great acoustics and very clean. Awesome that they have a bar and give you a grown up sippy cup to take your drink to your seat.

Beautiful theatre. Friendly and efficient bartenders and ushers.

This a small theater. I dont think you can have a bad seat. It has been renovated in its original style. Old fashioned Broadway. AND Book of Mormon was fantastic!

First trip to NYC and what an AWESOME show! Saw Book of Mormon, and talk about phenomenal. Had some champagne during and holy cow...they do not slouch. My finances options were small and large...he chose large haha turned out to be a glass of champagne as large as a normal beer! Great customer service of you ask me :D

My husband and I have been wanting to see this show for while now, but we were sorely disappointed with the experience we had considering the money we paid to see the show.1. When we went to purchase tickets at the box office the cashiers insisted that seats were filled and since it’s the holidays prices would be higher. The best price they could give us were seats where our legs would be squished for the duration of the show for $99/person. We eagerly accepted this deal. Our previous Broadway experiences had been so wonderful we felt it would be worth the money.2. We squished into our seats and as we watched all the guests file in we, along with the individuals sitting next to us, were surprised to see so many available seats in the theater. As I was walking to the bathroom, I overheard other patrons approaching the ushers explaining that they were separated from their group or had purchased the cheaper standing tickets. The usher pointed those individuals to prime seats in the orchestra area. The show began and they continued allowing individuals into the theater which obstructed our view and was greatly distracting from the first couple performances. The row above us and other seats in the theater remained empty for the entire show. We asked to move since we were so squished but the usher insisted we wait. Once intermission started we moved at once and were able to sit comfortably for the rest of the show. I just find it frustrating that when we bought tickets it was implied that those were the only seats available for an affordable price, but people who entered last minute and paid to stand were ushered into prime seats in the Orchestra.3. In addition, my husband went to buy drinks and the prices were outrageous—-$50 for a glass of wine and a beer. Also, there was something wrong with the speakers in the theater. I’m not sure if that was solely in the mezzanine or throughout the entire theater, but it was difficult to understand most of what the performers were singing.Last time we visited NYC we attended The Prom, sitting the the mezzanine, and The Phantom of the Opera, sitting then Orchestra. We experienced sitting in both areas of the theater and regardless of seat position had an amazing experience.This experience left me deeply disappointed and frustrated with the theater scene.

The theater is easy to find from the street. You walk into the building and are immediately in the theatre so its not hard to find our seat. The theater isnt too big either so you dont feel like youre a mile away if youre in the top back seats. The one downside is the bathroom setup which is just cramped, though understandably so.

Book of Mormon was amazing however being charged $75 for two drinks was pure daylight robbery - especially since the prices aren’t advertised and only after they’ve poured your drink do you get told how much it is. How on earth can you justify charging that much for two drinks?! So I highly recommend going to see the Book of Mormon (5 stars) but steer clear of the bar at this theatre (-5 stars)

Cool venue to see a okay right near Times Square and walking distance from Penn Station. Very good audio quality, could hear every line clearly and levels were not too high. Honestly great sound and lighting. Seats are standard quality and youll basically get a good view from any seat.

The theater itself is so so. The seats are small and jammed together. Book of Mormon was absolutely amazing, though! The actors mingled with the crowd afterwards, which was super nice. They were collecting donations, but still.