user
Pomona
8 W 58th St, New York, NY 10019, United States
Appearance

Comments
Sa
Review №1

Finest food, super friendly staff members, always excellent atmosphere. They charge reasonable prices and the food quality is excellent. 5 stars.

Je
Review №2

We are traveling for the holidays and stumbled across this hideaway restaurant. It wowed us from the stair way entry to the cuisine served. I ordered the Artic Char and it was so balanced. For dessert, we ordered the Baked Alaska and the Chocolate Mousse Espresso and, without a doubt in my mind, the chocolate mousse was off the charts. Everything was beautifully presented and wonderfully made! Thank you, Pomona!

Wa
Review №3

I like this restaurant! They have marvelous food, they have a rich menu, The chef in that place is a real pro, I like very much eating all their dishes. The food is consistently tasty, the attitude towards the customers is agreeable. I go often to this restaurant and I was never discontended. I recommend it to all.

Gr
Review №4

Absolutely a place worth stopping over, the food is good and well prepared, the cost is fair and it is always clean here. Keep up the good work.

eg
Review №5

Great new spot. Nice atmosphere with good and quality foodCool lounge on the back which called SavageMore interesting stuff at my Instagram @nazgool

Ti
Review №6

Pomona is absolutely fabulous! The atmosphere is hip and modern, but also perfect for those seeking an intimate dining experience. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and extremely accommodating. Every dish our server recommended exceeded our expectations. The cocktails were wonderful as well. I highly recommend dining at Pomona!

Ye
Review №7

Amazing food, great ambiance and service. The Savage Lounge is a great place to dance and have drinks with friends. Had my birthday party there this year. Also must try the truffle fries and the desserts!

Re
Review №8

Could go on and on about this place. Everything is well executed. The food was remarkable and cooked to perfection and the decor is incredibly tasteful. All in all a wonderful experience.

Am
Review №9

Ambience and cuisine are lavish! Pomonas new design from the former establishment is gorgeous. Like the goddess of fruitful abundance whose story it beholds, it blossoms with aliveness in Italian flair right in the most picturesque of locations. Chefs cuisine are truly a treat and worth experiencing! I had the butternut squash and burrata appetizer with the halibut entree and dined near the Real Housewives. Both dishes were exquisite and fresh, with surprising flavors of which you taste them all! I love halibut and I will honestly say, this was one of the best fish entrees Ive had. It was light and delicate for a heavier fish that is often overdone and healthily flavored with celery, olives, and a light broth. Preparation was perfect, the chef is warm and friendly, as also is the staff whom were inviting and in good spirits - Pomona was a charm that Ill be sure to return to! I would recommend for an outing with friends as it boasts a comfortable warm environment - or a date night (!) as it somehow mastered creating an ambience of colorful fun as well as passionately charming. Delizioso! Go!(I should have snapped a photo for the review but I too quickly devoured my food and was caught in the moment of enjoyment!)

Ma
Review №10

Pomona is exceptional. We were greeted at the door by attentive and friendly hostesses, who led us to coat check and then downstairs under dramatic stone arches. We emerged in the bar/dining room that was both modern and classic with touches of the namesake Pomona, Roman goddess of the harvest. Our dinner was exquisite (lobster, mackerel, black truffle escarole and mushroom “Diane”), and our cocktails were unique. My friend and I kept stopping mid-sentence to exclaim about the flavors. (Prometheus, GunSlinger, and Clover Club are must try.) It’s not easy to wow in this city of creative cocktails!Alex, who we learned used to be head bartender at speakeasy Gibson + Luce, made our night particularly memorable. Terrific service.Can’t wait to come back and see the adjacent lounge!!

Em
Review №11

Everything was AMAZING. Very fresh, amazing and innovative cocktails. Order the shrimp cavatelli and the ribeye. “The left behind” is a fabulous cocktail for those who love Japanese whiskey. The ambiance and service were great—look for a special spot behind the bookcase!

Da
Review №12

Excellent service. Staff is very attentive and knowledgeable. Decor is gorgeous. Very Casablanca vibe.

Ar
Review №13

I have a strong dislike of places that weasel money out of you by overcharging your credit card more than what you signed off on. I find it disgusting. Just noticed my credit card charge came in at a dollar more, after I clearly put a different number on the check total. And this is after I left a 20% cash tip. I wont be calling my credit card company over a dollar, but you just lost a rating. Hope it was worth it.

Ge
Review №14

Superb. Fresh and delicious seafood, service spot on. Will be back.

Ba
Review №15

Amazing Cocktails. The best Halibut in NYC. Also the lounge in the back is the perfect venue for drinks.

Da
Review №16

Great food, the night we were there they had a menu presented by the chef of Le Circ. Savage Lounge is in the back and a fun place, Snoop Dogg was a guest DJ when we were there.

Ne
Review №17

Very impressive. Well prepared and presented, everything met or exceeded my expectations, well done.

Do
Review №18

The service and food were exceptional! I recommend sampling many starters and entree’s. The oysters were amazing with a celery sorbet and the Mackerel Terrine with jalapeño broth wow! Then the entree’s slow cooked Halibut and Seared A-5 Miyazaki Wagyu absolutely crazy good! Then to end the Baked Alaska was the best dessert ever! Great music and service made Pomona a regular stop for me! Excellent!

Al
Review №19

Amazing food!! Salads and carrot mix were so good!!

Wi
Review №20

Wow! Not that I really Follow the whole Trendroid Celebuloid Star studded venues in NYC (I can always get in on any night, ahem...) BUT... The food here is something whacky! How do they offer such an amazing menu and afford Billionaires Rows sky high rents? It dont make sense! What does make sense is your bill at the end of a decadent meal! I work in the area and this is downright cheap (even the Halal Carts are pricey) come for lunch because dinner stacks up quickly... Speaking of quickly, after a few drinks we found ourselves in the depths of the restaurant in their Secret speakeasy (Remember the Celebs comment? Well...) Called Savage. It was Fierce! The bartender made certain I could only recall snippets of the night and Crowd (Bravo. Well played).. I plan on returning, hopefully to leave with more of a story (too many spots and fuzzy memories) than I saw that guy from that show. Or lady from that song... I shall keep my wits and update this review soon... Shhhh!!!

Ne
Review №21

Very generius frendly stuff / they go out of way to make home! No who are You bull shotUpscale comfy /beautiful crowd

Ro
Review №22

I loved how caring and attentive the staff was.

mi
Review №23

I cant get enough of the duck burger and halibut

Ma
Review №24

Great service

Ta
Review №25

Nice

Ro
Review №26

Steph said to save. Wants to go here. $38 duck burger.

Information
60 Photos
26 Comments
4.7 Rating
  • Address:8 W 58th St, New York, NY 10019, United States
  • Site:https://www.pomonanyc.com/
  • Phone:+1 212-753-1200
Categories
  • Night club
  • Bar
  • Cocktail bar
  • Lounge
  • Meal delivery
  • New American restaurant
  • Restaurant
Service options
  • Takeaway:Yes
Popular for
  • Dinner:Yes
  • Solo dining:Yes
Offerings
  • Coffee:Yes
Dining options
  • Dessert:Yes
Amenities
  • Bar on site:Yes
Atmosphere
  • Cosy:Yes
  • Romantic:Yes
  • Upmarket:Yes
Crowd
  • Groups:Yes
Planning
  • Dinner reservations recommended:Yes
  • Accepts reservations:Yes
Similar organizations