The Argyle Theatre at Babylon Village
34 W Main St, Babylon, NY 11702, United States

Review №1

If you love broadway, youll love the argyle theatre! It doesnt matter where you sit, its always a good seat. The performances, costumes, sets, choreography, and directing is professionally done and Ive always had a good viewing experience. First time season pass buyer right when Covid hit so hopefully they are up and running soon!

Review №2

The productions at this theatre are a must see! The showing of The Full Monty this season was my third show here and every time Ive been so impressed with the quality of talent and the level of workmanship in the costumes and sets. Perfect to bring family, or a date!

Review №3

This theatre and the talent which drive the productions is top notch. The theatre itself offers plush and very spacious seating. Every production I’ve seen there has been of the highest quality. The staff is welcoming and helpful. The ticket prices are very fair. I can’t say enough positive about The Argyle Theatre!

Review №4

We took my daughter to see the little mermaid and I was so thrilled!!! The talent on and behind the stage was so impressive that i cannot even put into words!!! The theater has the most comfortable seats with so much room. The staff is super helpful and friendly. I can not wait to go back to see sleeping beauty!! And maybe some adult shows too since they also sell beer, wine and soda!!!

Review №5

What a great venue! Took the grandkids to see the Happy Elf and it was fantastic! Our first time coming here. Will definitely come back for adult time too!

Review №6

Top quality theatre productions without the trip to the big city! Beautiful venue, went to watch my daughter perform the Nutcracker with Positions Dance Studio and enjoyed it very much. Other great productions on stage, looking forward to attending performances in the future.

Review №7

Great atmosphere in the area. Very homey and relaxed and an amazing little gem in babylon.we saw the little mermaid and it was an amazing performance with so many talented actors. The seats are very roomy and comfortable. Will definitely go again when we have the time.

Review №8

My family and I recently saw a production of The Little Mermaid here. We enjoyed it. The performance was great. The seating is comfortable. Concession was also available.

Review №9

This place is wonderful. Have seen many plays, which were very well done, and several tribute shows. The performances are always of the highest quality. The continue a tradition of excellent entertainment at a very affordable ticket price. The theater itself is well maintained and comfortable. Highly recommended.

Review №10

Shows are fantastic. They are Broadway quality. Performers are excellent and theater personnel are friendly and helpful. Anyone who loves live theater should check out The Argyle Theater. Avoid the hassle and high cost of going to Manhattan.

Review №11

Just saw the little Mermaid and I am in awe! What an amazing show! I’m still smiling at how great it was hours later!!! I just don’t even have words for how amazing it was and I can’t wait to come back and see something else! Bravo !!!!

Review №12

Great place to see a play. Plenty of leg room. Seats are nice and wide. Chairs needed to be staggered more to see in between people, otherwise it would have gotten 5 stars.

Review №13

Very nice,comfy seats with leg room,too. Snacks and drinks available. The show was as good as if I went into the City. I tell some many people about it.

Review №14

Its a cozy theater. The staff is pleasant. The ticket prices are reasonable. The seats are comfortable with good leg room. The shows have been top notch

Review №15

The performances are top rated. I took my grandbaby to see the Happy Elf. Seating is similar..actually better than.. Westbury Music Festival. The performances are top rated without the benefit of the New York stage. The schedule of venues is attractive and interesting enough for all generations.Top rated for sure!

Review №16

Sent my parents to see Million Dollar Quartet and they can’t stop raving. What a great Mother’s/Father’s Day gift! Sent my teenagers to see Spring Awakening this winter and I saw Hunchback of Notre Dame. All top notch productions. To sustain this excellent local theater, we must support this venue. Tickets and gift cards make great gifts for smart people who have everything!!!

Review №17

Live theatre so glad theres a place close by that i can go and watch a show with out traveling to the city and spending a fortune. There clean and comfortable and the father and son whom own it are very polite and friendly warm and welcoming people however the only down was theres a body oder smell i smelled the last 3x ive been there, Besides that Its incredible. I love the fact that i can get in my car and be home and in pjs by 11pm.

Review №18

Little Mermaid was terrific, preformed by a very professional, talented and wonderful troup. Excellent!

Review №19

Ive seen several shows at the Argyle, and all the performances have been high quality. The physical theatre itself is on par with some Broadway locations.

Review №20

Attended performance of The Producers. Amazing, top notch performance! Hard off to the cast, orchestra, and the theater. Wonderful to have great theater right in our own back yard. Dinner in the village, a fabulous show, and home in no time. Its a win-win-win!

Review №21

It was greatSaw little mermaid! Kimmy was great

Review №22

Awesome show. Great seats plenty of room. Owners are genuine. Give it a go!

Review №23

My friend Karen was in the play and it was a wonderful show and atmosphere.

Review №24

Saw legally blonde here. Very good. Seats are very comfortable - they must have changed the seats when they converted this place to a live theater.

Review №25

My family and I loved the Little Mermaid show!!

Review №26

Definitely local theater experience. The theater itself is big and very nice. The actors are very dedicated to their roles. We are lucky to have a place like this on Long island. Parking can be tricky (the lot next to the theater is small), but street parking can be found.

Review №27

Great place, sound and lights were great

Review №28

Saw million Dollar Quartet today took my aunt and mom cause it was “Their” time and it was awesome! Theses actors are all sooo good! Johnny Cash was insane! His voice and mannerisms are Johnny Cash spot on! Great show ! A must see you’ll be dancing!

Review №29

One of my favorite places to go. Always a fun time at the Argyle theater.

Review №30

Awesome venue every show is like going to the city but you dont have to.

Review №31

Broadway quality theatre without going to Broadway. Just paychecks at Rita Rudner! No seat is bad and the lobby bar is well stocked. Cant wait to see the Full Monty!

Review №32

We saw a great production of Legally Blonde there

Review №33

This is an amazing venue. Broadway on Long Island! They serve snacks, wine, water and beer! Love this place and will definitely be going back!!

Review №34

Outrageously professional productions stocked with equity-level talent, right around the corner at an historic venue. Only downside: The orchestra (specifically the trumpet) need to up their game.

Review №35

The Full Monty at the Argyle Theatre. Well performed - lots of fun!

Review №36

First time here and it was impressive! The show was great and the staff were helpful

Review №37

Entertaining performances, comfortable seating and great location close to home.

Review №38

Good theatre, the selection of plays, cast and creatives for the season are the result of a great artistic direction, congratulations

Review №39

Fun show. Very comfortable seat

Review №40

The new owners redid this theatre nicely. Hope it stays open for decades to come. We went to see the Hunch back and it was great.

Review №41

Amazing venue! I brought my 3 kids for the childrens theater show and they enjoyed every minute of it . I loved being back in the newly transformed theater , that I used to visit while growing when it was a movie theater. The owners did a great job at renovating the venue and really offering an amazing experience for every member of my family. I can not wait to go back!

Review №42

Theater is wonderful, show was great. I wish they had more bathrooms on the ground level.

Review №43

Great show. Little mermaid

Review №44

Great show...Hairspray. Very talented cast! Small theater so view is awesome any where you sit. Looking forward to seeing another show soon. Just wont be buying the combination tickets and Post Office Cafe dinner.

Review №45

Great way to see a Broadway play without traveling into the city! Could not believe the quality of talent!

Review №46

Very nice place, I will come for more shows to this establishment, more convenient than going to the city.

Review №47

Great local theater. Shows have been wonderful!

Review №48

Great local theater experience. Legally Blonde was a very enjoyable night out.

Review №49

Newly opened in a historical theatre. Great bar and concessions. Wonderful staff, great location to see a show and then walk to a restaurant.

Review №50

Wow! I saw Hairspray (not one of my favorite musicals but still enjoyable) and this production exceeded my expectations. Some of the actors have Broadway experience and it shows, the orchestra was live and rockin, and the production was first rate. After the show, the theater managers and the actors mixed with the audience in the lobby. You are getting top-quality theater for half the Broadway price. Cant wait to see more productions. Bravo!!!

Review №51

Went to see Hairspray tonight at Argyle theater.The performance was so professional. The actors were excellent. I saw the play on Broadway and thought this one was better.I had a great time for 50% off Broadway prices. Go see it and support local theater.

Review №52

Saw Spring Awakening this past season, it was incredible. The actors were extremely talented and the production was great!!

Review №53

The Argyle offers wonderful shows, great musical accompaniment and talented performers.

Review №54

This theater is one of the best Ive ever been in! The seats are comfortable, wide, and with the most legroom anywhere! Their production of Hunchback of Notre Dame was professional and top notch.

Review №55

Been there several times & was always great..good talent reasonable prices & so convenient

Review №56

Great Shows! Love the location! I have seen all of their shows, and they make each one unique and beautiful!

Review №57

Most excellent local theater. The theater itself is roomy and very comfortable. The show was amazing! I will definately follow their programs and attend more.shows!!!

Review №58

We saw Hairspray, and it was wonderful.The performers were top notch, and the choreography was perfectly synced. The theater itself is attractive, and the seats are roomy and comfortable. All the staff were extremely friendly and helpful. This is a wonderful local alternative to Broadway!

Review №59

I saw Peter and the Star Catcher and it featured fabulous acting. The story is a prequel to Peter Pan, but its a lot more unusual than that. Its not a real musical but features a bit of singing, and parts are quite humorous.

Review №60

Great theater. The show - Hunchback of Notre Damme - was amazing! We took both our kids (above age 8) and they too loved it and sat through the show great. The seating is ample and every single seat in the theater provides a good view. Theres parking on the side of the block and on the streets. A short guy who was at the entrance was rude (hence 1 star off).

Review №61

Well worth it. The children saw happy elf and loved every moment. They put a lot of effort into this and it shows!!

Review №62

Way too expensive Almost 2 times as much as Bayway and Creative Ministries

Review №63

The Million Dollar Quartet was wonderful! Bought season tickets again.

Review №64

Great show! Dont know anyone in it, but throughly enjoyed it!

Review №65

Broadway without the hassle of Manhattan, top quality production, excellent cast and sound system. The staff was very nice and accommodating. Will be back soon and looking forward to seeing their next production.

Review №66

Took my grandkids to see Legally Blonde ...converted movie theater eight no bad seat...they poved it!

Review №67

Fantastic, really enjoyed ourselves, the actors are very professional and should all be on Broadway, would definitely go back and look forward to the next time

Review №68

The music in Act 1 was much too loud. My wife put ear plugs in her ears. And we were sitting in the last row of the balcony!

Review №69

Excellent..........awesome great as any Broadway show and even better because its In Babylon.......the show was second to non.....Hunch back of Notre Dame. I will be going back. You need to check this out!

Review №70

Wow wow and more wow !!! Had an amazing date night out with my wife, as my BDay gift she got tickets for Hunchback of Notre Dame. From a very beginning of a warm Introduction from the Producers to an entire play, what a talent, voice and acting. Loved it, every second of it. Looking forward to Spring Awakening play next year. Thank you for memorable experience.

Review №71

They are the new theatre in town... But they entertain like seasoned veterans

Review №72

Enjoyable comfortable seat lots of leg room. Very nice , hard word great plays in your own back yard ;)

Review №73

Theatre experience without the traffic right in Babylon Village. Saw Hunchback of Notredame, and enjoyed the production and the venue. Nice spacious and comfortable seats and a surprisingly large stage.

Review №74

First time attending a play here, its a small theatre, dont feel there are any bad seats. Wide selection of items at the concession stand from hot chocolate to beer. Would definitely go back for another show

Review №75

Wonderful experienceThe cast did an excellent job. I will be going back

Review №76

I became a season pass holder when I went to the open house and got a preview of the Million Dollar Quartet. The Argyle Theater is like a Broadway but better.

Review №77

The shows are incredible, and such comfy seats! So nice to have such quality so close to home!

Review №78

Little Mermaid was amazing!

Review №79

Nice little theater, great seats, great acoustics, Million Dollar Quartet was a terrific show

Review №80

Saw the wizard of oz and the happy elf there with my daughters they did such a great job so much better then a movie live theater is the way to go. This is a gem for the village

Review №81

Saw Hairspray this evening 7/28. I must say it was very enjoyable, upbeat with a fine cast. Highly recommend you see it if you get the chance.

Review №82

Opening night for The Producers, very well done all around, really enjoyed the show and the orchestra was excellent

Review №83

Great performance of The Little Mermaid

Review №84

Wonderful environment fun show

Review №85

Beautiful, intimate theater.

Review №86

Over priced, floors are wavy, stage is to high its like watching a show from a hole.

Review №87

I was seeing movies here back in the seventies so its nice to see that theyve restored the theatre. Im going to see Guys and Dolls this week it should be good.

Review №88

Great place, friendly staff. Will definitely tell my friends. Well be back soon!

Review №89

No bad seat in the house. As good as Broadway!

Review №90

Saw the Hunchback of Notre Dame, and it was absolutely phenomenal. Would reccomend anyone to go see it, and Im looking forward to seeing the Producers this spring!

Review №91

By far the best playhouse out East!! Its a little NYC out in Long Island, what a treasure. The acting is superb. KUDOS!!!

Review №92

Love it!! Hidden gem! Best of luck to owners

Review №93

Great for kids, do not need to go to the city and see shows

Review №94

Great Theater! Professional union actors and actresses. Broadway in your backyard! Support your local theater.

Review №95

Nice place to spend a night after dinner to take in a show. Parking can be difficult.

Review №96

I have been here before and the show was always enjoyable. Last nights show had the audience standing, singing and applauding.

Review №97

We saw the show today, Hairstray...With friends... the show was Great..The actors were better than Broadway.So important for Babylon to have this Threatre.

Review №98

The Argyle Theatre is an absolute GEM, and a new, very exciting additional to the cultural landscape on Long Island. We have now seen both the iconic and well-known musical “Hairspray”, and the much more complex and thoroughly enjoyable recent Broadway hit, “Peter and the Starcatcher”. Both productions were SUPERB, and that is saying a lot, since particularly since “Peter” is an exceptionally demanding show for the actors, both in terms of the very witty and cerebral dialogue, and the fabulous choreography, which demands that the actors create the appearance of sinking ships, drowning seafarers, and hilarious mermaids. Without exception, the performers in both shows were top-notch, Broadway-quality stage performers. As for the theatre itself, it is a thoroughly renovated and exceptionally comfortable space, and all seats, both in the orchestra and balcony, have great sightlines. The staging, lighting and costumes are all top-notch and highly imaginative. We were accompanied to both shows by our daughter (who is a veteran of many high school and college live theatre productions) and our nine year old granddaughter, and we all had a great time at both shows. We intend to see every show that the Argyle puts on in their ambitious and varied six-shows-a-year schedule, and we became INSTANT season ticket holders at the intermission of out very first show at the Argyle. In a word : BRAVO !!!!!!!

Review №99

After seeing the review in Newsday I was skeptical about going Saturday night to see Guys and Dolls. So glad we did and they seem to a fixed anything negative that was said in Newsday. The show was great , the actors were great, the sound was great. I wish the Argyle Theatre all the luck in the world and we will definitely be back!

Review №100

Very clean and comfortable theater. Pinkalicious was fantastic!

78 Photos
4.8 Rating
  • Address:34 W Main St, Babylon, NY 11702, United States
  • Site:
  • Phone:+1 844-631-5483
  • Performing arts theater
  • Live performances:Yes
  • Wheelchair-accessible car park:Yes
  • Wheelchair-accessible entrance:Yes
  • Wheelchair-accessible seating:Yes
  • Wheelchair-accessible toilet:Yes
  • Good for kids:Yes
  • Family friendly:Yes
  • Cheques:Yes
  • Debit cards:Yes
  • NFC mobile payments:Yes
  • Credit cards:Yes
Similar organizations